Goodbye, my LiveJournal friends, for-EVAR!

by Brian Enigma on November 15, 2009 1:41pm

in Administrative

Yes, this post’s title invokes and evokes rule 1 of the Blog­donts that [info]sub­sti­tute posted years ago:

1.  [Do not] announce your depar­ture or hia­tus to the world. “Good­bye my Inter­net Friends For­ever” is always a mis­take. If you want to leave or go on a break, just do so. When you announce it, peo­ple feel that you’re beg­ging for com­pli­ments. Also, if you don’t absolutely mean it, you look like a total idiot when you come back the next day and post that “What Poke­mon are you” quiz. And if you’re try­ing to avoid evil stalk­ers, you just gave them free infor­ma­tion; don’t ever do that!

The real­ity of things is that I have not looked at my Live­Jour­nal friends page since Octo­ber 5th.  This is not through con­scious deci­sion (“good­bye, my LJ friends for­ever!”), but mainly due to con­ve­nience, work­flow, and wan­ing inter­est.  That’s not to say that I am dis­in­ter­ested in what folks have to say over there — I just do not always think about it and when I do, it almost doesn’t seem worth the effort of log­ging in, nav­i­gat­ing around, and read­ing the large back­log of missed posts.  I am not giv­ing up on Live­Jour­nal; I just find that it is less and less rel­e­vant to my interests.

I started writ­ing about my life in this thing called “a blog,” short for “web log,” back in August of 2001 after being intro­duced to the con­cept by [info]burn­ingskyz.  It caught on like wild­fire in my social group.  We all joined Live­Jour­nal and wrote about all vari­ety of things.  As RSS became more mature, I started using my journal’s friend list as a way of read­ing other blogs.  Even­tu­ally, I got myself a proper RSS reader and migrated those feeds out of Live­Jour­nal — split­ting my read­ing time between reader and jour­nal.  These days, my online read­ing time is mainly split between Google Reader and Twit­ter, with a touch of Face­book on the side. After toy­ing with LiveJournal’s poorly thought out OpenID imple­men­ta­tion (flawed in that I could read pro­tected entries but not com­ment on them), my online writ­ing moved com­pletely to my site (syn­di­cated to LJ via [info]brianenigma_rss).  LJ read­ing and writ­ing sim­ply dropped by the wayside.

I have sub­scribed to a few people’s jour­nals with Google Reader, which is nice but not a com­plete replace­ment for read­ing Live­Jour­nal.  One of the fea­tures that is unique to LJ — and used by many of my friends — is the abil­ity to post things as friend-locked entries. Obvi­ously, these do not appear in the RSS feed, and so I never see them in Google Reader.  I know of no easy way around this.  A cou­ple of months ago, some­one posted a squir­rely lit­tle Perl script to JWZ’s jour­nal that gets an RSS feed of all of your friends (not the default group or other sub-groups, but every­thing).  The out­put of that script would then have to be a public-ish RSS feed for Google Reader to ingest, and that com­pletely sub­verts the con­cept of posts being friend-locked by mak­ing them pub­lic enough for Google to see.  Given the choice of turn­ing people’s friend-locked entries to pub­lic (in a hid­den feed some­where, but still tech­ni­cally pub­lic) and sim­ply not read­ing LJ via Reader, I am choos­ing the latter.

So that is my long-winded way of say­ing Live­Jour­nal has got­ten old and while I have not com­pletely given up on it yet, the real­ity is that is has been a month and a half since I looked at it.  Good­bye, my Live­Jour­nal friends for another month and a half.  See you in the new year.

✻ ✼ ✻

P.S. If some­one really does know how to get LJ friend groups, includ­ing pro­tected entries, into Google Reader, then you are an amaz­ing per­son and must share this infor­ma­tion post-haste!  Mainly, I am look­ing for a solu­tion with the fol­low­ing features:

  • Allows me to view pro­tected entries within Google Reader, prefer­ably with an indi­ca­tor that the post is pub­lic ver­sus protected
  • Doesn’t require me to divulge a pass­word in plain­text (for instance, within a URL para­me­ter that can be seen in proxy logs, in OPML exports, or handed over to a 3rd party server/service)
  • Under­stands Live­Jour­nal groups.  I have groups defined on LJ for Cal­i­for­nia, PDX, ARGs, and what­not.  As I dis­cover and add new peo­ple on LJ, I really do not want to have to man­u­ally add them to the right groups on both LJ and Google Reader.  I know myself and know I’ll for­get an update.  They will quickly get out of sync.
Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Technorati

If you liked this post, you may also enjoy:

  1. LJProxy: From friend-locked Live­Jour­nal posts to Google Reader
  2. Live­Jour­nal and OpenID
  3. Digg Top Sto­ries -> RSS
  4. Google RSS Webu­la­tion Thinger
  5. Live dig­gna­tion in Port­land Ore­gon: Digg this to make it happen!

{ 8 comments… read them below or add one }

1 conrad November 15, 2009 at 1:50 pm

I can’t speak for anyone else, but if you stop reading my LJ via some method or other, you’re really not to hear what I have to say. Seems a shame to drop actual social connections because you don’t like a website.

Reply

2 Brian Enigma November 15, 2009 at 2:21 pm

As I mentioned above, not reading LiveJournal was not so much a conscious decision, but one of convenience and the migration of my attention to other venues. This post was mainly to bring that background behavior to the foreground. It is certainly not personal, and I don’t even see it as dropping social connections. Taking you as an example, I still read everything you write on Twitter and Facebook as well as your Flickr stream and Delicious links, I just miss out on some of the friend-locked LJ posts. My web history shows that I just seem to have lost interested in LiveJournal as a whole. Although I can make a few guesses, I cannot completely explain why. It is certainly nothing against individual users. As I live more of my online life in Twitter and Google Reader (and to some extent, the iPhone Facebook client), I find I have less time and interest in LiveJournal (and Digg and Unfiction — both of which I have not visited in longer than LJ, but this post wasn’t about either of those services). I last hit LiveJournal a month and a half ago. Previous to that, my mean-time-between-access had been between 2 and 4 weeks. That’s been the trend, whether I like it or not, and even despite my attempts to improve the frequency of my access a few months ago.

If I can safely get friend-protected posts into Google Reader, this whole post may just become a moot point.

Reply

3 Ariock November 15, 2009 at 1:56 pm

As a parallel issue, what blogging services (if any) are you aware of that allow one to post protected friends-locked entries that are readable in Google Reader? I mean, I’ve got not particular affection for LJ; however, I was never able to get it to import properly to my webserver’s Wordpress implementation. And I don’t see how I could have friends-locked Wordpress entries anyway.

Anyway. just some random musings.

Reply

4 Brian Enigma November 15, 2009 at 2:39 pm

I have only found two services that let you get friend-protected entries into Google Reader:

FeedProxy seems to promise an open-source solution (i.e. run it on your own server so that you do not have to share your password with a 3rd party). I cannot actually find the code, though. Also, based on the blog, it seems very on-again, off-again, with service outages measured in weeks as they get blocked by LJ and then re-added.

FeedProxy, as best as I can tell from the blog is not permanently down and suggests using FreeMyFeed. They seem to be closed-source and you just have to trust that they’re not going to divulge your password. The quote “…the password is encrypted in the URL using a rotating algorithm. Only the lead developer of the application even has full access to the encryption methods…” doesn’t make me feel safe and secure. Security through obscurity and “it’s so secure I can’t even break it myself” are big red flags all throughout Bruce Schneier’s writings.

With regard to importing LJ to Wordpress, I recall that I was able to import everything successfully back when I did it. I remember having to do an XML export at LJ, then importing those files into WordPress. I don’t know if it’s been streamlined since then or if they removed friend-locked posts for some reason. You’re correct in WP not having much by way of friend-locked entries. Technically, you can make posts password-protected or only visible if the user is logged in to your Wordpress installation, but neither of those methods are terribly practical. I’ve pretty much come to the conclusion that nothing on the internet is truly private, including friend-locked posts, and that the best way to keep something private is not to post it. If I keep private information to conversations with friends over beer then everything else can be posted publicly.

Reply

5 Brian Enigma November 15, 2009 at 5:01 pm

Oops, I re=read your comment and realized you were asking about alternative blogging services, not services that proxy LiveJournal. So far, I haven’t found any that have the ease of LiveJournal. The people running the LJ codebase (DeadJournal, etc.) have the same limitations. As I mentioned above, you can protect stuff in WordPress, but it’s a pain to end-users to read and not very RSS-able. You can do protected stuff on Facebook (via “Notes” that have their privacy tied to specific friend groups), but I think that’s even worse than LJ on the RSS front. Beyond that, I’ve seen nothing. Most of the blogs I read that belong to individuals are WordPress (either hosted at WordPress.com or with copy of WordPress.org’s software running on their own site) or Blogger, and simply don’t post private information. LiveJournal appears to be one of the few (along with MySpace and Facebook) with friends-only blog posts — and none have an easy way of getting them outside of the walled garden.

Reply

6 jes5199 November 16, 2009 at 12:12 am

I’ve been using a terrifying concoction of FreeMyFeed plus Yahoo Pipes to create a separate, friends-only-posts feed for each of my LJ friends. I have a ruby script that generates the OPML for this. It ignores Livejournal groups, but it could probably be tweaked to use them.
It’s here if you care: http://github.com/jes5199/free_my_livejounal_with_opml

Reply

7 Brian Enigma November 16, 2009 at 10:34 pm

I keep telling myself that one of these days I need to learn Git and/or Ruby. Maybe this weekend is the time!

Reply

8 Gregory McIntyre December 22, 2009 at 7:06 pm

I’m trying this out. I’m pretty excited. It seems to be working. I only had to change one line:

-FoafURI = “http://#{Username}.livejournal.com/data/foaf”
+FoafURI = “http://#{Username}.livejournal.com/data/foaf”.gsub(‘_’, ‘-’)

I’d like to make it 1 RSS feed for each person, including public and protected entries (maybe with a little icon or tag to qualify each entry as public or private) and it would put a link to the number of comments at the bottom of each entry too.

I’ll see if I can manage it. :P git branch ahoy.

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: